Three Dangers of Redundancy [...]

Normal Accident Theory articulates three dangers of redundancy, summarized by Scott Sagan as follows.

  • Redundancy increases complexity, generating “common-mode” errors. Example: Fermi Reactor safety device added at last minute breaks off and blocks coolant pipe.
  • Redundancy may lead to decreased sense of responsibility among workers. Example: Diffusion of responsibility among AWACS operators led to no one passing needed information to F-15 pilot. See Bystander Effect
  • Redundancy may lead to increased production pressures due to perceived safety. Example: Injuries increase when helmets added to a sport.

Examples and breakdown from “Learning from Normal Accidents” (pdf)

Normal Accident Theory see accidents as “normal” and has related insights.

A related issue is Alarm Fatigue

Source: Three Dangers of Redundancy

Wikity users can copy this article to their own site for editing, annotation, or safekeeping. If you like this article, please help us out by copying and hosting it.

Destination site (your site)
Posted on